MBL | Biological Discovery in Woods Hole Contact UsDirectionsText SizeSmallMediumLarge

Resources for Reporters:

MBL Publications:

Join the Conversation:
Facebook Twitter Youtube Wordpress

Nobel Laureates

press releases

For further information, contact the MBL Communications Office at (508) 289-7423 or e-mail us at comm@mbl.edu

EMBARGOED until 2 pm (EST), October 22, 2009
Contacts: Gina Hebert, MBL, 508-289-7725; ghebert@mbl.edu

Climate Scientists Uncover Major Accounting Flaw in Kyoto Protocol and Other Climate Legislation

Fix needed to reduce future large-scale land conversion and resultant greenhouse gas emissions


Jerry Melillo

Jerry Melillo, Senior Scientist, Marine Biological Laboratory. Click for high-resolution image.

About Jerry Melillo (pdf format)

Melillo Lab page

The MBL Ecosystems Center

June 16, 2009:
Jerry Melillos Leads New Comprehensive Climate Report

MBL, WOODS HOLE, MA—An international team of top climate scientists has found a critical, but fixable, error in the accounting method used to measure compliance with carbon limits. The flaw, which centers on the measurement of CO2 emissions from the use of bioenergy, could undermine greenhouse gas reduction goals if not addressed.

Current carbon accounting, used in the Kyoto Protocol and other climate legislation including the European Union’s cap-and-trade law and the American Clean Energy and Security Act, does not factor CO2 released from tailpipes and smokestacks utilizing bioenergy nor does it count emissions resulting from land use changes when biomass is harvested or grown. This, the scientists say, erroneously treats all uses of bioenergy as carbon neutral, regardless of the source of the biomass, and could create strong economic incentives for large-scale land conversion as countries around the world tighten carbon caps.

In a paper published in the October 23 issue of Science magazine, Marine Biological Laboratory (MBL) senior scientist Jerry Melillo and a dozen co-authors contend that across-the-board exemption of CO2 emissions from bioenergy is improper in greenhouse gas regulations if emissions due to land-use changes are also not included. “The potential of bioenergy to reduce greenhouse gas emissions inherently depends on the source of the biomass and its net land-use effects,” the authors write.

Land-use emissions stemming from bioenergy use vary widely. Clearing established forests to burn wood or grow energy crops results in large releases of CO2 while converting unproductive land to support, for example, fast-growing grasses, may result in net carbon reduction. Under the current carbon accounting system, both scenarios are counted as a 100% reduction in energy emissions.

“When forests or other plants are harvested for bioenergy, the resulting carbon release must be counted either as land-use emissions or energy emissions,” says Melillo. “If this is not done, the use of bioenergy will contribute to our greenhouse gas problem rather than help to solve it.”

Melillo and his colleagues say the accounting flaw is fixable and call for a system that would track the actual flow of carbon and count all CO2 emissions, whether from fossil fuels or bioenergy. They further recommend that any crediting system for assessing bioenergy consider changes in carbon reserves; emissions of other damaging greenhouse gases other than CO2, such as nitrous oxide; as well as land-use emissions.

“The error is serious, but fixable,” said lead author Tim Searchinger, a research scholar at the Princeton Environmental Institute and a fellow with the German Marshall Fund of the U.S. “The solution is to count all the pollution that comes out of tailpipes and smokestacks whether from coal and oil or bioenergy, and to credit bioenergy only to the extent it really does reduce greenhouse gas emissions.”

“Bioenergy has the potential to provide a substantial amount of energy and help nations meet greenhouse caps, but correct accounting must be in place to prevent unintended consequences of unsustainable bioenergy production,” adds Melillo.


The MBL is a leading international, independent, nonprofit institution dedicated to discovery and to improving the human condition through creative research and education in the biological, biomedical and environmental sciences. Founded in 1888 as the Marine Biological Laboratory, the MBL is the oldest private marine laboratory in the Americas. For more information, visit www.MBL.edu.